HP vs. Kardeş Yazıcı 2024

Two of the biggest players in the laser printer game are HP and Brother. IDCIt sold approximately 45% of all printers purchased globally in the first quarter of 2024. Both manufacturers offer a variety of printers, from cheap and cheerful to big, powerful and frighteningly fast. If you’re choosing between HP opposite brother printersThis depends on three factors: price, reliability and performance.

Let’s look at each of these factors and which manufacturer has the upper hand. Also, be sure to check out the following when searching between HP and Brother printers: best laser printers And best home printers for your needs.

Best for:

• Print to budget
• Low volume printing needs: single letters, labels, etc.

Skip in the following cases:

• You print too much
• You need the best quality

---

Best for:

• Low printing cost
• Getting a machine that is easy to use
• Having a no-frills toner that’s easy to refill

Skip in the following cases:

• You need large print volumes

---

HP vs. Brother Printer: Price and Value

Too Close to Search

My budget laser printer choice was: Brother HL-L2460DWIt’s a $160 printer that’s great value for money. However, HP LaserJet Tank MFP 2604SDW Printer At around $200, it’s a bit pricier, but it has a significant advantage over Brother when it comes to printing cost per page. When you need to start buying new toner, HP costs less than a cent per page, while Brother costs about 3 cents per page.

Of course, both the Brother HL-L2460DW and the HP LaserJet Tank come with toner in the box; This toner can last several years with occasional use. So if you only use the printer occasionally, the price per page may not matter that much. But if you’re doing high-volume printing, HP wins here because it’s more affordable in the long run.

---

HP vs. Brother Printer: Reliability

One is Known for His Endurance

Printer reliability can sound complicated, especially considering that printers can fail suddenly and often at the worst of times. During my extensive testing, I found both printers to be reliable. Both are renowned for their durability, but Brother has a slightly better overall reputation for making its devices last longer. In comparison, HP is only slightly behind. With proper care and recommended maintenance, both printers will last a long time.

In general, multifunction devices are less reliable than their single-function counterparts because they are more complex. The Brother HL-2460DW is a simpler printer because it does one thing: print. HP LaserJet Tank MFP 2604 printing and scanning both involve moving pieces of paper in complex ways along two separate paths. More moving parts means more parts jammed or jammed, which can affect lifespan. And of course, many manufacturers have problems with these complex devices failing over time.

There is a clear winner when comparing reliability. If you only need to print, go for the Brother printer.

---

HP vs. Brother Printer: Performance

Both Produce Clear Text and Images

In my testing of both Brother and HP printers, I found that they both produced excellent results with sharp, clear text and bright, bold colors. Below I tested some enlarged black-and-white and color samples from the HP LaserJet Tank and Brother HL-L2460DW color laser printers. These are the files I use: 1040 tax form from the IRS And Color gamut image from Wikipedia.

There were differences, though: the Brother printers I tested produced text that was slightly crisper and sharper than the HP printers, while the HP perhaps had a slight edge in reproducing greys.

This depends on what your specific printing needs are. In either case, they are both very good printers capable of producing crisp text and color images, although each has strengths that outshine the other.

---

HP vs. Brother Printer: Verdict

It’s All About Factors

Both companies make great printers that can effectively handle the printing tasks you need, or do more when you need to scan, copy, and fax. The choice depends on more specific feature options and cost per page.

In my testing, I found that multifunction devices like the HP LaserJet Tank offer a wider range of features, but you should consider what you need: Will you be paying extra for features you’ll never use, like copying and faxing? The HP LaserJet Tank costs much more than the Brother, but it does so much more. It also costs less per page, but that’ll only make a real difference if you’re printing a lot: Many consumers I spoke to didn’t replace the toner in their printers for several years after purchase because they didn’t replace the toner. Use this much. If you only print text at home or don’t need all the extra features HP offers, the Brother printer is also a great choice.

---

How Did I Test HP? Brother Printers

I tested HP and Brother laser printers by running a series of tests to evaluate print quality, speed, and approximate cost of a typical page.

• I tested print quality by printing a variety of documents, including photos, presentations, web pages, and others, and then evaluated the quality and color accuracy of the prints.
• Print speed was tested by printing multiple copies of the five-page ISO/IEC 24712:2007 test document from a PDF file on a USB flash drive or from a USB-connected computer. I measured the time from pressing the print key until the first page dropped into the output tray (called startup time) and then the time it took to print 12 copies of this document: 60 pages in total.
• Print speed calculated using the entire duration, including startup time, to reflect typical user experience. I also tested the software to use the printer from Windows PCs, Macs, and portable devices such as iPhones.
• Print cost was calculated by taking the cartridge cost and dividing it by the ISO yield of the high-capacity print cartridge (or cartridges for color prints).

---

My expertise

I’ve been reviewing consumer tech hardware since 1992, when 3.5-inch floppy disks were cool and laptops still weighed nine pounds. Since then, I’ve tested a wide range of products, from coffee makers to Wi-Fi routers, for publications like Wired, Tom’s Guide, and PCWorld.

My expertise is in creating new testing guidelines for products across many different publications and establishing rigorous methodologies to ensure you are truly purchasing the best products on the market. I have reviewed thousands of products over the years. best home printers And best smart locksand I understand how the right technology can make a difference in everyday life.